Usman vs. GSP: The Welterweight GOAT Debate That’s Dividing MMA Fans

The image of Kamaru Usman and Georges St-Pierre side by side has reignited one of MMA’s most heated debates: who truly deserves the title of welterweight GOAT? As a lifelong MMA fan, I’ve watched both men dominate their eras with such different but equally impressive styles that choosing between them feels almost impossible.

Two Welterweight Legends, Two Dominant Eras

When GSP was in his prime, he seemed untouchable. The Canadian superstar combined technical striking, world-class wrestling, and fight IQ that was years ahead of his competition. His nine consecutive title defenses remain the gold standard at 170 pounds.

But then came “The Nigerian Nightmare.” Usman’s 15-fight UFC win streak included five title defenses where he showcased devastating power that GSP never quite possessed, alongside wrestling credentials that rivaled the Canadian’s grappling mastery.

Breaking Down the GOAT Debate

Let’s compare these titans across categories that truly matter:

Why GSP Still Holds the Edge (For Now)

While Usman’s peak might have shown more raw finishing power, it’s GSP’s longevity and ability to reclaim gold after a devastating loss to Matt Serra that separates him. The Canadian’s ability to reinvent himself throughout his career – from explosive athlete to technical master – showcases an evolution Usman hasn’t had to make yet.

Plus, let’s not forget GSP’s final act – moving up to middleweight and choking out Michael Bisping to become a two-division champion. That’s something Usman hasn’t accomplished.

Usman’s Case for the Throne

The “what if” game strongly favors Usman. Had that head kick from Leon Edwards missed by inches in their rematch, we might be talking about Usman surpassing GSP’s defense record. His dominance over Colby Covington – arguably the second-best welterweight of his era – cannot be overlooked.

What’s most impressive about Usman was his improvement with each fight. The guy who grappled his way past Tyron Woodley evolved into the striker who knocked out Jorge Masvidal in spectacular fashion.

The Cultural Impact: Beyond the Octagon

GSP transformed MMA in Canada, turning it from niche sport to national obsession. Usman, meanwhile, helped lead the UFC’s expansion in Africa alongside Israel Adesanya and Francis Ngannou.

Both men transcended the sport in different ways – GSP with his squeaky-clean image and mainstream appeal, Usman with his compelling immigrant story and representation for African fighters.

What the Numbers Don’t Tell You

Stats don’t capture how GSP fought in an era where specialized fighters still existed. He faced wrestlers who couldn’t strike and strikers who couldn’t wrestle. Usman competed when every contender was well-rounded, making his dominance arguably more impressive.

Yet GSP fought through the steroid era when testing was minimal, while Usman competed under USADA’s watchful eye. Context matters in these debates.

The Final Verdict

For now, GSP retains the welterweight GOAT status by the slimmest of margins. His championship longevity, two-division success, and ability to avenge every loss give him the edge.

But Usman’s career isn’t over. At 37, there’s still time for him to reclaim gold and add to his legacy. This debate might look very different in two years.

What do you think? Is Usman already the welterweight GOAT, or does GSP’s resume still stand supreme? The beauty of MMA is that these debates keep evolving as new chapters unfold.

Who’s Next to Challenge for GOAT Status?

Keep your eyes on Belal Muhammad and Shavkat Rakhmonov. Both undefeated welterweights have the potential to insert themselves into this conversation in the coming years. The 170-pound division’s legacy wars are far from settled.

Source: Bloody Elbow